Should the no torture rule apply to people like the vegas shooter?

1. Boards
2. Politics
3. Should the no torture rule apply to people like the vegas shooter?

SkuIItuIakid 2 days ago#1 Do demented mass murderers deserve to pay dearly through torture? - Results (109 votes) Yes! People that massacre others deserve to pay dearly through excruciating torture! 14.68% 16 No! That wouldn't be very nice or humane. 85.32% 93 I wish the no torture rule didn't apply to these demented evil pieces of S***! They deserve torture within an inch of their life, for as long as they can be kept alive! Honestly they deserve much more than that, but that's the most we can mortally make them pay for all of the families, lives, and happiness they have destroyed! But of course our society is too "humane" to do this. They'd rather have them sit quietly in a cell, or use the death penalty through "painless" means (edited 2 days ago)stickyreportquote

hoax123 2 days ago#2 The vegas shooter is dead, what do you suggest we do? Torture his already dead body? Lock her up! reportquote

VRX3000 2 days ago#3 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. ~ - ~ On second thought, I want my old signature back reportquote

LewsTheDragon 2 days ago#4 VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. Fantastic. Faith means not wanting to know what is true. Friedrich Nietzsche  I'm a polyatheist -- there are many gods I don't believe in. reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#5 VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. We aren't trying to get info out of them. Just trying to make them feel and realize all the pain they caused people reportquote

TheGreatDebate 2 days ago#6 Let’s think of painful methods of torture in this topic. Take a nail and stick it underneath the person’s big toe. Then hammer it in. Take a dagger. Soak it in salt and lemon juice. Stab person anywhere. You don't need to stop sinning before coming to Jesus. Come to Jesus with your sins and you will see your life change. reportquote

McSame_as_Bush 2 days ago#7 No, and capital punishment in and of itself is wrong. The Republican Prayer: ''Let's not linger on what I said yesterday, what matters is what I am saying today, and I'll have further details for you tomorrow.'' reportquote

hoax123 2 days ago#8 TheGreatDebate posted... Let’s think of painful methods of torture in this topic. Take a nail and stick it underneath the person’s big toe. Then hammer it in. Take a dagger. Soak it in salt and lemon juice. Stab person anywhere. Personally, i still think the most painful torture is death by burning. Ofc, i dont expect any answers from people who are set on fire, so if its information you are after, you can rule this one out. Lock her up! (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

TheGreatDebate 2 days ago#9 hoax123 posted... TheGreatDebate posted... Let’s think of painful methods of torture in this topic. Take a nail and stick it underneath the person’s big toe. Then hammer it in. Take a dagger. Soak it in salt and lemon juice. Stab person anywhere. Personally, i still think the most painful torture is death by burning. It’s not good torture if they die! But that is one way I would hate to die. You don't need to stop sinning before coming to Jesus. Come to Jesus with your sins and you will see your life change. reportquote

hoax123 2 days ago#10 TheGreatDebate posted... hoax123 posted... TheGreatDebate posted... Let’s think of painful methods of torture in this topic. Take a nail and stick it underneath the person’s big toe. Then hammer it in. Take a dagger. Soak it in salt and lemon juice. Stab person anywhere. Personally, i still think the most painful torture is death by burning. It’s not good torture if they die! But that is one way I would hate to die. Burning to death isnt torture because you die at the end? Its still torture all the way until the point of death. Lock her up! reportquote

myusernameislame 2 days ago#11 SkuIItuIakid posted... VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. We aren't trying to get info out of them. Just trying to make them feel and realize all the pain they caused people That has no tangible benefit to anyone. reportquote

TheGreatDebate 2 days ago#12 hoax123 posted... TheGreatDebate posted... hoax123 posted... TheGreatDebate posted... Let’s think of painful methods of torture in this topic. Take a nail and stick it underneath the person’s big toe. Then hammer it in. Take a dagger. Soak it in salt and lemon juice. Stab person anywhere. Personally, i still think the most painful torture is death by burning. It’s not good torture if they die! But that is one way I would hate to die. Burning to death isnt torture because you die at the end? Its still torture all the way until the point of death. I was kidding. :/ You don't need to stop sinning before coming to Jesus. Come to Jesus with your sins and you will see your life change. reportquote

G_I_B_B_O_N 2 days ago#13 Would love it. Mortal Kombat X, Overwatch and Dark Souls matches https://youtu.be/vCiHx2v1Gc4 (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#14 myusernameislame posted... SkuIItuIakid posted... VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. We aren't trying to get info out of them. Just trying to make them feel and realize all the pain they caused people That has no tangible benefit to anyone. Psychological benefit for people like me and the victims that would love to see people like paddock PAY! (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#15 Also I think the torture should be aired on national TV for public satisfaction, and to dissuade other demented pieces of s*** from doing the same thing! Kinda like the old days when people were hanged along that bridge in London to send a message. "You massacre people, this is what you get" (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

G_I_B_B_O_N 2 days ago#16 SkuIItuIakid posted... Also I think the torture should be aired on national TV for public satisfaction, and to dissuade other demented pieces of s*** from doing the same thing! Kinda like the old days when people were hanged along that bridge in London to send a message. "You massacre people, this is what you get" and the profits of the spectacle sent to the victims families Mortal Kombat X, Overwatch and Dark Souls matches https://youtu.be/vCiHx2v1Gc4 reportquote

hoax123 2 days ago#17 SkuIItuIakid posted... Also I think the torture should be aired on national TV for public satisfaction, and to dissuade other demented pieces of s*** from doing the same thing! Kinda like the old days when people were hanged along that bridge in London to send a message. "You massacre people, this is what you get" There is a problem with that kind of thinking. You think it would "persuade" people to not do crimes, but it doesnt work like that. We have higher crime rates than many countries, despite the fact that our justice system is harsher than most of them. Lock her up! (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

BetaSquadron 2 days ago#18 OP, go on liveleak, look up the torture of Samuel Doe, and tell me if it gives you any satisfaction. reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#19 BetaSquadron posted... OP, go on liveleak, look up the torture of Samuel Doe, and tell me if it gives you any satisfaction. What did he do? reportquote

Trelve 2 days ago#20 SkuIItuIakid posted... myusernameislame posted... SkuIItuIakid posted... VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. We aren't trying to get info out of them. Just trying to make them feel and realize all the pain they caused people That has no tangible benefit to anyone. Psychological benefit for people like me and the victims that would love to see people like paddock PAY! Surely the greater benefit is seeing someone like him behind bars for the rest of his life. Wanting to see someone tortured in front of you says more about you than anyone else. reportquote

G_I_B_B_O_N 2 days ago#21 Trelve posted... SkuIItuIakid posted... myusernameislame posted... SkuIItuIakid posted... VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. We aren't trying to get info out of them. Just trying to make them feel and realize all the pain they caused people That has no tangible benefit to anyone. Psychological benefit for people like me and the victims that would love to see people like paddock PAY! Surely the greater benefit is seeing someone like him behind bars for the rest of his life. Wanting to see someone tortured in front of you says more about you than anyone else. It says he hates people who cause massive amounts of death and suffering and wishes to inflict on them what those people have done to others instead of having tax payers fund a comfy lifestyle behind bars where they gets shelter and food at no cost for the rest of their lives. Prison is a reward for these kinds of people. Pretty understandable and relatable imo that he feels that way. Maybe you should get off your high horse. Mortal Kombat X, Overwatch and Dark Souls matches https://youtu.be/vCiHx2v1Gc4 (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

Kradek 2 days ago#22 No, because then you fall into the vengeance category.  I support the death penalty for very extreme scenarios and he's definitely one I would have wanted executed. But not by torture. "I'm a baby killer, baby killing makes me horny. Aliens inside me, gonna squash it like Sigourney" ~Get Dat Fetus, Kill Dat Fetus - Sextina Aquafina reportquote

G_I_B_B_O_N 2 days ago#23 Kradek posted... No, because then you fall into the vengeance category.  I support the death penalty for very extreme scenarios and he's definitely one I would have wanted executed. But not by torture. Nothing wrong with wanting vengeance. Revenge does often times help people feel better when they have been wronged. Mortal Kombat X, Overwatch and Dark Souls matches https://youtu.be/vCiHx2v1Gc4 reportquote

The_Undying_84 2 days ago#24 First of all, let me just say f*** you for your stupid f***ing bait and switch poll with a question that is the reverse of the topic title. And the answer is torture is always wrong. And in this case is completely pointless. Torture doesn't even work anyways so it's ALWAYS pointless, but there is no useful intel to acquire here even if it did work, the guy was a lone wolf. bloop reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#25 G_I_B_B_O_N posted... Trelve posted... SkuIItuIakid posted... myusernameislame posted... SkuIItuIakid posted... VRX3000 posted... 1) We have a law against cruel and unusual punishment 2) Torture...actually doesn't do much of anything beneficial. We've seen throughout the entire Iraq war that torturing people for information just gives false leads. People just say whatever you want to hear, even if it is fake. All our good information came when we were nice to people. So really the entire concept of torture is just for your own personal satisfaction and not for any actual strategic advantage. We aren't trying to get info out of them. Just trying to make them feel and realize all the pain they caused people That has no tangible benefit to anyone. Psychological benefit for people like me and the victims that would love to see people like paddock PAY! Surely the greater benefit is seeing someone like him behind bars for the rest of his life. Wanting to see someone tortured in front of you says more about you than anyone else. It says he hates people who cause massive amounts of death and suffering and wishes to inflict on them what those people have done to others instead of having tax payers fund a comfy lifestyle behind bars where they gets shelter and food at no cost for the rest of their lives. Prison is a reward for these kinds of people. Pretty understandable and relatable imo that he feels that way. Maybe you should get off your high horse. This^^^ reportquote

Atombender 2 days ago#26 Forced confessions are worthless. "Another visitor! Stay a while! Stay forever!" reportquote

Kradek 2 days ago#27 G_I_B_B_O_N posted... Kradek posted... No, because then you fall into the vengeance category.  I support the death penalty for very extreme scenarios and he's definitely one I would have wanted executed. But not by torture. Nothing wrong with wanting vengeance. Revenge does often times help people feel better when they have been wronged. It's not justice, though. Justice has to be impartial and vengeance is literally the polar opposite of that. "I'm a baby killer, baby killing makes me horny. Aliens inside me, gonna squash it like Sigourney" ~Get Dat Fetus, Kill Dat Fetus - Sextina Aquafina reportquote

the final bahamut 2 days ago#28 If you don't care about human rights, then you don't care about freedom or democracy. While I'm not going to ask you to move to Saudi Arabia, I am going to ask you to keep your bloodthirsty bile out of public debate. "The US military is not an effective proxy for humanity" ~ Folding Ideas Faciendere id pro RAVz reportquote

David-Bowie 2 days ago#29 if you really care about human rights for anyone you have to care about human rights for everyone R.I.P. (1947-2016)  THE Brother Man in the Motherland. Shaft is stickin' it...all the way. reportquote

Genericgamer667 2 days ago#30 will torture bring back the victims or heal their families? No It's not about that, it's about making you feel good Switch FC: SW-0826-5923-7882 NNID: Seadrake It is a remake, not my fault you people think ports are remakes (but only on Nintendo systems)-Demondog666 reportquote

PostCrisisJ2 2 days ago#31 I don't see the point of torturing a corpse. spritual powah will never die Don't be shy to drop a PM to me, I'm always open for conversation. reportquote

VullabySaysHi 2 days ago#32 I would have preferred he stayed in a rehabilitation prison for 20 years and learned what he did wrong so he could have a normal life once more instead of being tortured. Just some hype. reportquote

KD003 2 days ago#33 Let's be honest. It's gonna get abused. It'll end up with black people getting tortured for stealing a bagel or whatever. There is no SFV Message Board. Only Reek now. http://imgur.com/opZ0laf reportquote

IShall_Run_Amok 2 days ago#34 SkuIItuIakid posted... Psychological benefit for people like me and the victims that would love to see people like paddock PAY! It wouldn't be any particular benefit to the victims' families. Contrary to popular belief, the families of murder victims are not sexual deviants or bloodlusting animals. And if they were, that doesn't mean we should indulge them. As for you, I recommend putting more effort into controlling your bizarre fetishes. These baby smashing hammers are great! reportquote

DOAbayman 2 days ago#35 when are you planning your massacre OP? you clearly share the same sadistic and psychotic mentality "Are you one of those scrubs that likes the story spoon fed to you?" "You mean books?" reportquote

acolytes 2 days ago#36 TC sounds like a psychopath. Empty the Tanks. Ivory Free. reportquote

Background_Guy 2 days ago#37 TC and Gibbon should be institutionalized tbh reportquote

zeppelin4ever42 2 days ago#38 Torture also recruits for the enemy and gives credence to propaganda against us We should avoid it entirely Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#39 Background_Guy posted... TC and Gibbon should be institutionalized tbh Nothing wrong with wanting a top criminal to experience the wrongdoings that they have done to others. reportquote

BetaSquadron 2 days ago#40 Did you watch the vid? reportquote

CherryTsundere 2 days ago#41 No! That wouldn't be very nice or humane. 84.93% Thanks 'Cause I'm a primadonna girl, yeah All I ever wanted was the world reportquote

IMadepooh4U 2 days ago#42 Mandatory waterboarding. The ancient Oracle said that I was the wisest of all the Greeks. It is because I alone, of all the Greeks, know that I know nothing- Socrates reportquote

PurplePanda8 2 days ago#43 Why would we torture this person? To make you feel good? Criminal justice shouldn't be society taking revenge on a person. reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#44 PurplePanda8 posted... Why would we torture this person? To make you feel good? Criminal justice shouldn't be society taking revenge on a person. To make the mass murderer feel what he made others feel. It's only fair (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

BetaSquadron 2 days ago#45 Hello? @SkuIItuIakid did you watch the vid? reportquote

SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#46 BetaSquadron posted... Hello? @SkuIItuIakid did you watch the vid? You haven't told me what the guy did yet reportquote

BetaSquadron 2 days ago#47 Samuel Doe was a repressive dictator. reportquote

Alesandros 2 days ago#48 Torture is ultimately self-defeating. Classically liberal, independent moderate. US Marine and Pianist. [Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/AlesandrosX?feature=mhee] reportquote

Thebrah 2 days ago#49 SkuIItuIakid posted... But of course our society is too "humane" to do this. They'd rather have them sit quietly in a cell, or use the death penalty through "painless" means Do you know why? Because people who suggest such remedies, those that are peaceful and "humane" as you so like to sardonically dub it, don't suffer from the painful torment experienced in the lives of people who mass murder others. Those people aren't "humane" because they suffer deeply within. They lash out and make others suffer for their inner suffering. They need help and the ability to talk to others about their problems, and warn others of their coming bottled up pain. They need to come out and confess of these things before they do them, and those that do not should be studied to figure out why they do not. Or we can just take your "inhumane" approach and f***ing torture them potentially to death until they tell us more about themselves, LMAOOO.  I mean, get a clue. Learn science. Most capitalists don't know that you can't become rich without doing the opposite of Jesus Christ's golden rule. Maybe that's why rich folk don't go to heaven. reportquote

Thebrah 2 days ago#50 Dude shows up talking about crazies like how Trump talks about Kim Jung Un. "Buncha rocket men. They keep that s*** up we'll just have to burn them in a blaze of fury. Who with me, breh?" Save these s*** topics for tweeting. Most capitalists don't know that you can't become rich without doing the opposite of Jesus Christ's golden rule. Maybe that's why rich folk don't go to heaven. reportquote

1. Boards
2. Politics
3. Should the no torture rule apply to people like the vegas shooter?
   
   1. Boards
   2. Politics
   3. Should the no torture rule apply to people like the vegas shooter?

   luigi33 2 days ago#51 No. What does it do? It won't bring back the dead. It will do absolutely nothing for the families of the victims. Its an absolute waste of money. 3DS FC: 5370-0672-9935 Steam ID: Xcyper33 reportquote

   IMadepooh4U 2 days ago#52 luigi33 posted... No. What does it do? It won't bring back the dead. It will do absolutely nothing for the families of the victims. Its an absolute waste of money. Deterrence. The ancient Oracle said that I was the wisest of all the Greeks. It is because I alone, of all the Greeks, know that I know nothing- Socrates reportquote

   zeppelin4ever42 2 days ago#53 IMadepooh4U posted... luigi33 posted... No. What does it do? It won't bring back the dead. It will do absolutely nothing for the families of the victims. Its an absolute waste of money. Deterrence. So they'll make sure to die instead of get captured, leading to no information Not to mention it literally recruits for the enemy Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me reportquote

   mrplainswalker 2 days ago#54 Obviously, it needs to apply to everyone or it's worthless as a policy. If you only torture the "bad" people, then it just becomes an arbitrary determination of what counts as "bad". It's like punching a round bottom dummy. We all know it's futile, but occasionally it's fun. - willythemailboy on the subject of stray orcas reportquote

   SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)2 days ago#55 mrplainswalker posted... Obviously, it needs to apply to everyone or it's worthless as a policy. If you only torture the "bad" people, then it just becomes an arbitrary determination of what counts as "bad". Kind of like the death penalty. Chosen for specific extreme cases like this (edited 2 days ago)reportquote

   zeppelin4ever42 1 day ago#56 SkuIItuIakid posted... mrplainswalker posted... Obviously, it needs to apply to everyone or it's worthless as a policy. If you only torture the "bad" people, then it just becomes an arbitrary determination of what counts as "bad". Kind of like the death penalty. Chosen for specific extreme cases like this USER INFO: SKUIITUIAKID  Veteran User Since: Feb 2017 Karma: 217 Active Posts: 36 Total Badges: 7 Hmmmm.... Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me reportquote

   atmasabr 1 day ago#57 For what cause would we have to torture him? The United States already has an enhanced interrogation program that we use to find out if more plots are incoming. Once we know the answer to that question, there is no reason not to proceed the usual way. Do your own research! reportquote

   SkuIItuIakid (Topic Creator)1 day ago#58 atmasabr posted... For what cause would we have to torture him? The United States already has an enhanced interrogation program that we use to find out if more plots are incoming. Once we know the answer to that question, there is no reason not to proceed the usual way. Why is everyone thinking this would be for gaining information? The reason to do this would be for retribution. To make mass murderers feel what what they made others feel. reportquote

   IShall_Run_Amok 1 day ago#59 SkuIItuIakid posted... Why is everyone thinking this would be for gaining information? I think I read your intentions pretty clearly, and as I said, you should do something to control your bizarre sexual fantasies. These baby smashing hammers are great! reportquote

   acolytes 1 day ago#60 Eye for an eye isn't justice. Like the death penalty, I oppose things like this because you could convict the wrong person. Empty the Tanks. Ivory Free. reportquote

   Icewitch 1 day ago#61 We should have a real life Hunger Games with the 12 worst criminals each year. May the odds be in your favor. ^.^ reportquote

   mrplainswalker 1 day ago#62 SkuIItuIakid posted... Kind of like the death penalty. Chosen for specific extreme cases like this Wait, you're talking about using torture as a punishment? That's even worse than I thought. It's like punching a round bottom dummy. We all know it's futile, but occasionally it's fun. - willythemailboy on the subject of stray orcas reportquote

   1. Boards
   2. Politics 
   3. Should the no torture rule apply to people like the vegas shooter?